They both sound awesome....very well played.
In J-marts version (who is an absolute perfectionist freak of nature on the old VH stuff) the harmonics during the part where Dave sings "gotta bleed baby" sound a SLIGHT bit higher from the original for some strange reason.
In Eric's version I think that the phaser is just a bit too wet causing it to go in and out of tune (which is what a phaser does), but mixing in a bit more dry holds the line better.
I'll obstane from voting on this one...they are both great. However anyone with the kahonaas that challenges J-Mart to a VH duel can pretty much start digging before they even get started. I don't think Ed himself could take him on and win.