I think the few responsed has a little to do with the recording quality. We've been so spoiled with great recordings with pods and v-amps and stuff like that, so something thats just all recorded through a mic like this can be a bit hard to listen too.
With a bit of compression and reverb the vocals would probably sound ok, and the guitar work sounds good. Very good for only playing about a year!
Either way it sounds like you two had fun doing this, so keep it up!