Okay, REALLY listened to it, and I have some comments:
elecjoy - NICE playing. Very clean, tight and nice phrasing. I could really hear you "breathing" The harmony was nice too.
bbkane - I don't know how I feel about your tone you used.. I think I find it just a touch to fuzzy, but if that's what you want then kudos to you
Playing was right on, the only part was the tapping, but that wasn't even bad so nice job! I DO really like the leading and "mis"leading lines in the background. Awesome!
andrewtheshreddr - Not bad at all! The beginning - was that a harmonizer or was that just a few takes? Very cool. The ONLY thing I'd mention is make sure all your notes are "clean" as possible - it's not so bad by itself but takes away a little bit from the harmonies. Otherwise, nice note selection.
mickey_g107 - Man, I got the blues... OHHHH The blues. Excellent phrasing, nice use of the "less is more" philosophy. I like it. Very well played as well!
The mix: Only suggestion is that I'd maybe bring the keys up to the same levels as the guitars, and the backing was very subtle expecially when there was harmonies going on. I personally like to hear them compliment each other *leads and backing rather* but the backing was very quiet in this one. Again, not a bad thing, just a stylistic thing and that's very much up to the "producer"
All around, very very well done guys. Pat yourselves on the back. Great job!